#2 | AsCollected

Introduction

Every AsCollected includes two tables; Table 1 shows author roles, Table 2 data provenance.
Authors are able to edit those tables at any point
Changes made after a project is public are done with tracked-changes on
This project is public but currently anonymous (enabling blind peer-review).

--- Click Column Header to See Definition Here ---

Raw data: First digital copy of the data

Final data: Digital copy of data which have already been cleaned (e.g., removing columns/rows, recoding values, replacing missing values, renaming variables).

Analysis code: This author wrote less than 20% of the code necessary to analyze the data, but inspected the code written by another author.

Cleaning code: This author has a copy of the scripts used to clean the data

Analysis code: This author wrote at least 20% of the code necessary to analyze the data

Cleaning code: This author wrote less than 20% of the code necessary to clean the raw data, but inspected the code written by another author.

Cleaning code: Cleaning data involves tranforming variables, merging datasets, dropping rows, etc.

Cleaning code: This author wrote at least 20% of the code necessary to clean the raw data.

Copy of raw data: This author has, as of this writing, a copy of the raw data

Copy of final data: This author has a copy of the data, from this specific datasource, that are needed for reproducing the relevant results in the paper

Obtained raw data: This is the author who received the raw data (e.g., the author on whose account a Qualtrics survey was run, or who received the email with a spreadsheet from an RA or 3rd party)

Analysis code: This author has a copy of the scripts used to analyze the data

	DATA		CODE
Study 1 Gameshow Data	3	2	1 2 3	3	2	1 2 3	3	2	1 2 3
Study 2 Lab data	1	1	1 2 3	1	--	1	1	--	1
Study 3 Prolific	1 2 3	1 2 3	1 2 3	1	2	1 2 3	1	2	1 2 3

DATA

CODE

Raw

Final

Data Cleaning

Data Analysis

obtained

has copy

wrote

reviewed

has copy

wrote

reviewed

has copy

Study 1
Gameshow Data

1 2 3

Study 2
Lab data

1 2 3

Study 3
Prolific

1 2 3

	When	Where	Data ID	Non-authors	Additional Info
Study 1 Gameshow Data	Obtained 2024-07-01 1	Obtained from https://moralchoice.mbc.com/archive 1	Unique data ID? No 1	RAs involved Yes 1	Anything else: The data are freely available from that website, and have been archived in the webarchive. Obtaining the data:Full-length recordings of the game show we (read more) Anything else: The data are freely available from that website, and have been archived in the webarchive. Obtaining the data:Full-length recordings of the game show were downloaded from the above URL. Four research assistants [anonymized] watched and coded each episode, putting their scores on a shared google sheet. Data cleaned: With code 1
Study 2 Lab data	From - To 2025-06-01 2025-06-03 1	Data source: lab computer saving locally Lab location: Computer lab in [anonymized], at [anonymized] 1	Study ID: TEU 2025-44[anonymized] 1	Support staff: We received assistance from two RAs [anonymized] and the lab manager [anonymized] Creating the dataset: Each computer has software that saves to a networ (read more) Support staff: We received assistance from two RAs [anonymized] and the lab manager [anonymized] Creating the dataset: Each computer has software that saves to a network folder, an author [anonymized] loaded all the individual datafiles in R and saved a single .csv file that was shared with the other two authors. 1	Data cleaned: With code Anything else: Nothing else. 1
Study 3 Prolific	From - To 2025-08-01 2025-08-01 1	Pool: Prolific Data ID:64a1b2c3d4e5f6789012abcd 1	Platform:Qualtrics ID: SV_9Z0Xy1234ABCDef 1		Data cleaned: With code 1

When

Where

Data ID

Non-authors

Additional Info

Study 1

Gameshow Data

Obtained
2024-07-01

Obtained from
https://moralchoice.mbc.com/archive

Unique data ID? No

RAs involved Yes

Anything else: The data are freely available from that website, and have been archived in the webarchive.
Obtaining the data:Full-length recordings of the game show we (read more)

Study 2

Lab data

From - To
2025-06-01
2025-06-03

Data source: lab computer saving locally
Lab location: Computer lab in [anonymized], at [anonymized]

Study ID: TEU 2025-44[anonymized]

Support staff: We received assistance from two RAs [anonymized] and the lab manager [anonymized]
Creating the dataset: Each computer has software that saves to a networ (read more)

Data cleaned: With code
Anything else: Nothing else.

Study 3

Prolific

From - To
2025-08-01
2025-08-01

Pool: Prolific
Data ID:64a1b2c3d4e5f6789012abcd

Platform:Qualtrics
ID: SV_9Z0Xy1234ABCDef

Data cleaned: With code

Table 1: Author roles

Table 2: Data collected